Highfield Rangers
1991
First Round - Group 415-09-1991Highfield RangersLeicester 0-2 
1992
1st Round - Group 7Bye
2nd Round - Group 704-10-1992Highfield RangersRainworth Miners Welfare 2-6 
1993
First Round19-09-1993Leicester CityHighfield Rangers 3-2 
1994
First Round18-09-1994Peterborough DiamondsHighfield Rangers 0-11 
Second Round16-10-1994Highfield RangersSolihull Borough 2-3 
1995
First Round17-09-1995Highfield RangersCalverton MW 4-2 
Second Round15-10-1995Whalley RangersHighfield Rangers 0-4 
Third Round12-11-1995KilnhurstHighfield Rangers 2-4 
Fourth Round03-12-1995Ilkeston Town RangersHighfield Rangers 5-0 
1996
First Round29-09-1996Leek TownHighfield Rangers 1-2 
Second Round03-11-1996Highfield RangersChester City 4-2 
Third Round01-12-1996Highfield RangersOldham Athletic 1-0 
Fourth Round19-01-1997Highfield RangersBerkhamsted Town 2-3 
1997
First Round28-09-1997Highfield RangersCambridge United 6-0 
Second Round02-11-1997Loughborough StudentsHighfield Rangers 4-4 [1]
Second Round09-11-1997Highfield RangersLoughborough Students 2-1 
Third Round30-11-1997Bloxwich TownHighfield Rangers 6-1 
After Extra Time  [1]
1998
First Round27-09-1998Highfield RangersBloxwich Town 3-0 
Second Round01-11-1998NettlehamHighfield Rangers 0-3 
Third Round13-12-1998Highfield RangersCoventry City 1-3 
1999
First Round10-10-1999Highfield RangersKidderminster Harriers O-W [1]
Walkover for Kidderminster Harriers  [1]
2000
First Round29-10-2000Highfield RangersLichfield Diamonds 5-1 
Second Round12-11-2000Chesham UnitedHighfield Rangers 6-5 
2001
First Round28-10-2001Highfield RangersOadby Town 7-0 
Second Round11-11-2001Lincoln CityHighfield Rangers 3-1 
2002
First Round27-10-2002Highfield RangersLichfield Diamonds 5-6