Appleby Frodingham
2011
First Qualifying Round02-10-2011North Ferriby UnitedAppleby Frodingham 4-0
2012
First Qualifying Round30-09-2012Appleby FrodinghamRothwell 0-12
2020
Extra Preliminary Round06-09-2020Appleby FrodinghamSouth Cave Sporting Club 4-3
Preliminary Round20-09-2020Brighouse SportsAppleby Frodingham 6-1
2021
First Qualifying Round12-09-2021Appleby FrodinghamGrimsby Borough 0-7