| Prudhoe Town | | 2008 | | Preliminary Round | 21-09-2008 | | Newcastle Medics | Prudhoe Town | 1-4 | | 1st Qualifying Round | 28-09-2008 | | Prudhoe Town | Blyth Spartans | 0-5 | | 2009 | | Preliminary Round | 13-09-2009 | | Prudhoe Town | RACA Tynedale | 1-3 | | 2010 | | 1st Qualifying Round | 03-10-2010 | | Prudhoe Town | Percy Main | 1-6 | | 2011 | | 1st Qualifying Round | 02-10-2011 | | Ashington CFC | Prudhoe Town | 3-2 | | 2012 | | 2nd Qualifying Round | 14-10-2012 | | Prudhoe Town | Penrith AFC | 2-5 | | 2013 | | 1st Qualifying Round | 22-09-2013 | | Prudhoe Town | Kader | 0-2 | | 2014 | | Preliminary Round | 07-09-2014 | | Rutherford | Prudhoe Town | 4-1 | | 1st Qualifying Round | 28-09-2014 | | Peterlee RA | Prudhoe Town | 4-2 | |
|
| 2015 | | 2nd Qualifying Round | 20-09-2015 | | Boldon | Prudhoe Town | 5-0 | | 2016 | | 2nd Qualifying Round | 18-09-2016 | | Prudhoe Town | Hartlepool United | 0-9 | | 2017 | | 1st Qualifying Round | 03-09-2017 | | Prudhoe Town | Chester Le Street Town | 2-5 | |
|
| 2023 | | 1st Qualifying Round | 10-09-2023 | | Prudhoe Town | Bishop Auckland | 4-1 | | 1st Qualifying Round | 17-09-2023 | | Prudhoe Town | Bishop Auckland | 1-3 | |
|
|
|
|